See Inside This Infamous Murder House in East Hampton

The scene of the infamous 2001 murder recently sold for more than $8 million.

59 Middle Lane in East Hampton, New York was the scene of financier Ted Ammon's headline-making murder in 2001. The home, which his children inherited, sold in December. Scroll down for a look inside.

The six-bedroom house sits on 2.2 acres in East Hampton.

Ammon was found bludgeoned to death in the home in 2001, court documents report.

"Fifty percent of people would rule it out because of the history," listing agent Judi A. Desiderio of Town & Country Real Estate told the Wall Street Journal. She said that after some potential buyers learned about the house's past, which she was legally required to disclose, they "wouldn’t even go in."

Because of that, Desiderio said the buyer got "an incredible deal" on the house.

He or she paid somewhere north of $8 million for the estate in December (the exact figure has not been reported, and Desiderio said she couldn't reveal it yet).

Still, she said the home needs a full renovation.

The buyer, whom Desiderio said "was one of several tenants that absolutely fell in love with the house while they were there," is now considering whether to gut-renovate the house or tear down it down and start anew. "It needs a lot of work," she said.

The 7,000-square-foot English Manor-style home was first listed for $12.7 million.

The price was then chopped to $11.7 million, followed by $10.995 million.

A documentary produced by Ammon's adopted son, 59 Middle Lane, tells the story of the murder.

It also explores twins Greg and Alexa Ammon's search for their birth parents in Ukraine.

The twins were the sellers; their mother, Ted Ammon's estranged wife Generosa, died of cancer in 2003.


Her reported lover, Daniel Pelosi, was convicted in 2005 of Ted's murder. He is serving a prison sentence of 25 years to life and maintains his innocence.

It previously rented for around $250,000 per summer.

"We had three tenants that fell in love with it and wanted to buy it," Desiderio said, "but the family wasn't ready to sell" until last year.

The home comes with a heated swimming pool.

Whether the structure stays the same or gets razed remains to be seen.

*This story originally appeared on

*Minor edits have been made by the editors

View More Articles About:
About The Author
Sam Dangremond
View Other Articles From Sam Dangremond
Latest Stories
These new scents will excite your olfactory senses with their modern takes on classic ingredients.
Because "lazy dressing" just doesn't cut it sometimes.
In honor of Meghan and Harry's trip to Australia, New Zealand, Fiji, and Tonga, we break down the planning process.
Kensington Palace just announced that Meghan and Harry are expecting their first child.
The Duchess was just gifted an adorable stuffed kangaroo with a joey and booties.
Ideas that go way beyond the traditional altar.
Congratulations to the Duke and Duchess of Sussex!
Interior designer Jonathan Matti was the sole Filipino at the intimate de Gournay dinner at Lord David Cholmondeley's Norfolk Estate.
Whether you're a single traveler, on vacation with a partner or with your family, try these underrated experiences in Bohol.
Load More Articles